Um... what did I just say? Sorry about that. That's a totally misleading title to this blog post. When I said "smoking," I didn't mean cigarettes, cigars, pipes, vapes, and the like. I meant smoking as in a method of cooking. No nicotine patches required, just wood chips and patience... although this can be quite an addictive habit!
🦃 Turkey vs. 🐖 Boston Butt: The Smoker’s Showdown
Ladies and gentlemen, welcome to the backyard arena! In the left corner, weighing in at a deceptively lean 16 pounds, the Turkey. Known for its dry personality and tendency to panic under pressure, this bird requires hours of therapy in the form of brining (dry only, please! I need to probably do a whole article on the benefits of dry brining, especially poultry for a juicy, not-dried-out poultry outcome — no foul fowl or fowl fouls, please!), butter massages (ok, I didn't actually do that for yesterday's bird), and constant reassurance that yes, it is the centerpiece of Thanksgiving (we have tended to start branching out of "typical" Thanksgiving/Christmas/Easter meals, but come on, Turkey Day earned that nickname for a reason!). One wrong move and it turns into sawdust with drumsticks.
In the right corner, lumbering in at a marbled 8–10 pounds, the Boston Butt. Don’t let the name fool you — this cut is all shoulder, all swagger. It’s the heavyweight champion of low-and-slow cooking, forgiving mistakes like a benevolent uncle who’s seen it all. Too much smoke? Still delicious. Forgot to spritz? No problem. This pork practically wants to be smoked.
Round 1: Flavor Absorption
Turkey: Absorbs smoke like a sponge, but only if you babysit it.
Butt: Laughs at your wood choice and still tastes amazing.
Round 2: Cook Time
Turkey: 3–4 hours if you’re lucky (yesterday's 16-pounder came in at 2.5 hours‼️ we'll get to the details in a bit), plus the stress of timing it with Aunt Linda’s arrival (note: I don't have an Aunt Linda, at least not that I know of, but it seems like a fitting name; my mom is actually named Linda, and unfortunately she didn't arrive yesterday, on purpose — she was just coming back from a Thanksgiving vacation and spent the day with her sister, my Aunt Peggy, in north-central Alabama, hours away from us down near the coast).
Butt: 8–10 hours (yesterday was closer to 11), but it’s basically a set-it-and-forget-it marathon.
Round 3: Crowd Reaction
Turkey: Polite applause, followed by whispered debates about dryness.
Butt: Standing ovation, chants of “ONE MORE SLICE!” echo across the yard (note: we pull the pork butt, rather than slice it, so the chants aren't quite like that).
Verdict: The turkey may win on tradition, but the Boston Butt dominates on flavor, forgiveness, and fan loyalty. If this were fantasy football, the turkey is your risky boom-or-bust FLEX play, while the butt is your reliable RB1 grinding out points every week. (Note: my fave is the turkey... especially now that I've learned how to keep it juicy with a good dry brining!)
🔥 The Science of Smoke (Sort Of)
Now, let’s get nerdy for a second. Smoke isn’t just “meat perfume” wafting around your backyard — it's basically edible fog made of tiny flavor particles that cling to proteins and fats like needy fans at a boy band concert. Technically, you’re flavoring your food with controlled combustion. Sounds dangerous, tastes delicious.
Different woods bring different personalities to the party:
Hickory: The linebacker of smoke woods — bold, aggressive, and guaranteed to tackle your taste buds.
Apple: The sweet wide receiver — light, fruity, and perfect for turkeys that need a little charm.
Pecan: The balanced quarterback — smooth, nutty, and capable of running the whole offense without breaking a sweat.
Mesquite: The wildcard kicker — strong, unpredictable, and occasionally ruins Thanksgiving if you don’t watch the clock.
Cherry: The diva of smoke woods — adds a rosy blush to your meat like it just got back from vacation, with a sweet, slightly tart flavor profile that makes turkeys strut and pork butts purr.
Think of smoke as seasoning that takes hours to apply. Salt works in seconds, pepper in minutes, but smoke? Smoke is the slow-burn hype man, building anticipation until your guests are drooling like Pavlov’s dogs. Yesterday's play: Apple and Cherry base (~50/50 mix), with a little hickory thrown on top. Why? We were going to be doing both Pork and Turkey in the same smoke, so we needed something that would complement both meats, while not overpowering the bird.
🛠️ Scenario Mapping (a.k.a. My All-Night Meat Vigil)
Smoking isn’t just cooking — it’s time management theater. And much like theater, 1) you're not likely to have a perfect performance; and 2) you gotta be ready to pivot, roll with the punches, and perform on two broken legs. Yesterday’s performance went something like this:
7:00 PM: Smoker lit (ok, turned on... I have an electric smoker; don't judge, it's easy!), dialed in at 235°F. The stage is set, the wood is burning, and optimism is high. Don't forget to put water in the water tray — along with maybe some apple cider vinegar and perhaps a little cooking sherry.7:30 PM: Boston Butt enters the ring. It’s a marathoner, settling in for the long haul.
Midnight: Turkey joins the party. Smoker cranked to 275°F. I whisper encouragement: “See you at breakfast, bird.” Expectation: alarm set for 6 AM, wake to find things approaching readiness.
2:20 AM: Plot twist. The turkey decides it’s done early, like a student turning in the exam halfway through. Pulled, wrapped, and stashed in a 170°F oven while the butt keeps puffing away. Just in case there's any lingering uncooked turkey meat, this will get 'er done, and being fully wrapped in foil, should be low enough to avoid drying out the tender white meat. (Yes, I checked the other breast and both legs with an instant read meat thermometer... perhaps I should swap my dual wireless meat probe for a quad-probe model.)
2:30–6:00 AM: Me vs. sleep. Spoiler: sleep loses. I toss, I turn, I check temps like a paranoid parent monitoring a baby monitor. Somewhere in that timeframe I managed about an hour of broken sleep in two 30-minute stretches. This is going to be a long, long Thanksgiving day!
6:00 AM: Butt finally taps out, tender and triumphant. Wrapped, stashed in the cooler like a prizefighter resting after victory. It'll keep just fine there (lunch target: 1 PM).
Morning encore: Turkey returns to the smoker at 150°F, just hanging out until the lunch crowd arrives. Because apparently, smoked poultry needs an encore performance. The 150 setting should keep the bird above the 140-degree danger zone while, hopefully, not drying anything out. (Spoiler alert: it worked!)
The moral of the story? Smoking meat is less “set it and forget it” and more “set it, obsess over it, lose sleep, and then brag about it.”
Here's a full visual timeline summary (for those of you who like pictures more than words):
![]() |
| Warning: prolonged exposure to smoked meats may cause spontaneous backyard parties. |
🏁 The Finish Line: Where Meat Meets Meaning
![]() |
| The Setting |
![]() |
| The Smoker |
🔧🌡️🔥 The Equipment
- EAST OAK 30" Electric Smoker — generally, in practice, with a good wireless thermometer, the window is not really needed. In fact, it's usually not all that useful, as it gets covered with smoke and moisture and isn't all that easy to see through. Some will argue that electric isn't as nice as pellet or whatever, and probably they're right — but, hey, electric is so easy and I have yet to complain about the food that comes out of it, and you just have to plug it in, no charcoal or gas (yes, you do still have to do the prep of adding wood chips and the water in the tray). It does a good job of regulating the temp on its own, too. It's not super fancy or anything (no app or wifi connection), but it does a good job, I think (and I think most who have consumed its production would agree). I also bought the stand for it (brings the smoker grills, water tray, and wood container up a little higher for us old folk, and makes it easier to move around, too, since the wheels are nicer than the ones on the smoker itself) and the cover (probably unnecessary, but keeps the elements off when it's not in use). Aside: I should probably apply for an Amazon affiliate account — because apparently my smoker is working harder than I am! 😆
- Typhur Sync Gold Wireless WiFi Meat Dual Thermometer — great for keeping track of the meats you're smoking. Its initial estimate to completion is usually pretty wrong, but eventually it will get close. Note that the thermometers will NOT transmit through foil, but sometimes I'll leave it in there anyway so I can get a quick read on the temp when pulling back out of the cooler or whatever. It's nice that it transmits to the base which connects to wifi, so that you can keep track of it wherever you go. But recently I've been failing to get alerts on my phone; I might need to check that Android didn't silence those alerts from me somehow by reigning in permissions on "unused apps" (since I don't use the smoker every day, maybe it decided that the Typhur Sync app is "unused" and doesn't need any permissions).
- Alpha Grillers Meat Shredder Claws — yeah, not a necessity, but who doesn't want to feel like Wolverine while pulling the BBQ?
- Oklahoma Joe's® Disposable BBQ Gloves — keeps the hands clean AND unburnt while wrestling with hot, juicy things. When pulling meat from the grill, put the included cotton gloves on first, then the neoprene gloves over that. The cotton insulates your hands from the heat, while the neoprene keeps the cotton clean and keeps any hot juices from soaking through the cotton onto your tender skin (well, my skin seems tender, but then again, I'm probably just a wimp; hopefully your smoked meat is just as tender as your skin — no, hopefully it's more-so!).







